NEWS

Law Blog

In Beauchamp v. New York City Tr. Auth., 252 A.D.3d 1051(N.Y. App. Div. 1st Dep’t 2026), New York’s Appellate Division, First Department, reviewed a jury verdict in favor of a pedestrian who was struck and dragged by a city bus. The court reduced several of the awards as excessive but upheld the overall verdict, describing the total as perhaps among the largest personal injury awards ever approved by an Appellate Division.

In March 2017, a bus making a left turn on East Houston Street in Manhattan struck the plaintiff, then sixty-two, while she was crossing in the crosswalk. She was dragged and pinned beneath the bus for about twenty minutes before first responders could free her. The defendants conceded liability, so the trial concerned only damages, including her husband’s claim for loss of services as her full-time caregiver. The plaintiff suffered devastating injuries, including a complete lumbosacral plexus avulsion, nineteen rib fractures, and crush and degloving injuries. She continues to live with chronic pain, complex regional pain syndrome, and recurring infections.

The jury had awarded the plaintiff $25 million for past pain and suffering, $32 million for future pain and suffering, and $8.5 million for future medical expenses, and her husband $3 million and $4 million for past and future loss of services. The court found the pain and suffering and loss of services awards excessive and reduced them to $20 million, $17 million, $1.5 million, and $1.1 million, respectively, unless the plaintiffs agree to the reductions, in which case a new trial is avoided. It also reduced the future medical award to $8,238,345, the amount supported by the plaintiffs’ experts, because the additional procedures were unlikely to ever be performed due to the risk of infection. Even so, the court concluded that the reduced awards were reasonable compensation, noting that defense counsel did not identify a New York case with comparable injuries and a lesser award.

This decision shows that courts will closely scrutinize large verdicts but will uphold substantial compensation when the injuries are catastrophic and well documented. It also shows how important expert testimony is in proving future medical needs with reasonable certainty.

Giulia R. Marino, Esq.

Secret Link