NEWS

Law Blog

In Olivares v. Andacky, 252 A.D.3d 1427(N.Y. App. Div. 2d Dep’t 2026), a plaintiff drove out of a gas station and across two or three southbound lanes of Westminster Road in Nassau County, attempting to turn left onto the northbound side. A truck traveling in one of the southbound lanes collided with the plaintiff’s vehicle before the maneuver was complete. After discovery, the defendant moved for summary judgment, which the Supreme Court granted.

The court noted that a driver with the right-of-way must still try to avoid a collision, but that a driver who has only seconds to react to a vehicle that failed to yield is not comparatively negligent. Using deposition testimony from both drivers, the defendant showed the plaintiff was negligent in crossing multiple lanes of traffic, citing provisions of the Vehicle and Traffic Law. The testimony also established that each driver saw the other’s vehicle only about a second before impact. The plaintiff offered nothing to create a factual dispute, and the Appellate Division affirmed the dismissal.

This decision shows that mere seconds are not always enough to establish comparative fault in a motor vehicle case.

Giulia R. Marino, Esq.

Secret Link