NEWS

Law Blog

The doctrine of “assumption of risk” is addressed in C.P.L.R. 141, which was enacted in 1975.  It is applicable only in very particular circumstances where a participant takes part in a sport and/or recreational activity, and the danger inherent in the activity is obvious and necessary.  The participant in such an activity must be aware of the risk, appreciate the nature of the risk, and voluntarily assume the risk.  Exceptions to these are if the risks are hidden or unreasonably enhanced.

In the New York Court of Appeals decision Grady v. Chenango Valley Central School District et.al. (2023 WL 3102723, decided on April 27, 2023), two cases within the context of high school athletics and concerning the doctrine of assumption of risk were reviewed.  In Secky, the plaintiff, while playing basketball, was injured during a drill in which teammates competed to retrieve a rebound ball.  The plaintiff sustained a serious injury to his shoulder when another player collided with him and caused him to fall into the bleachers.  The Court affirmed defendants’ motion for summary judgment (thereby dismissing the case) because it held the plaintiff’s injury was inherent in the sport of basketball and therefore, he assumed the risk of injury.  However, in Grady, the plaintiff sustained vision loss in one of his eyes while participating in a complex baseball drill involving multiple balls being thrown and protective screens set up on the field in various locations.  In this case, the Court reversed the lower courts’ granting of defendants’ motion for summary judgment – thereby restoring the case – because it held the use of screens and the complexity of the practice/drill created a unique and dangerous condition that rose above the usual inherent dangers in this particular sport and within the context of a high-school athletics program (and as a result, the Court held that one does not assume the risk of same).

Of interest in this decision is the dissent by Justice Rivera, who concurs in Grady but dissents in Secky (a dissent is when a Judge disagrees with the majority decision of the Court and states their own opinion after the decision).  Justice Rivera discusses the legislative intent of C.P.L.R. 1411, which “expressly abolished contributory negligence and assumption of risk as absolute defenses,” and that the intent of the legislation was to allow plaintiffs to recover in part for injuries they are partially liable for.    Justice Rivera further analyzes the broad interpretation of the definition of “recreational activity,” as well as discusses in detail numerous publications on the abuse and retainment of the assumption of risk doctrine in the court system.  Justice Rivera suggested that assumption of risk should be abolished, and such an abolition will not cause the dire consequences to sporting events and activities suggested in prior case analysis, and a comparative fault analysis is sufficient in these cases.  Justice Rivera further stated that the Court should reverse both Grady and Secky and remit for trial with juries instructed on comparative fault.

More recently, the New York Court of Appeals decided two golf-related injury cases together, both involving the primary assumption of risk doctrine.  In Katleski v. Cazenovia Golf Club, N.Y.3d 212(N.Y. 2025), a golfer was struck in the eye by a ball from an adjacent hole during a tournament. The court held that the claim was barred, because being hit by a stray ball is an inherent risk of golf and he did not show that the course design increased that risk beyond what is customary.  In Galante v. Karlis, a woman was injured when her golf cart collided with a car in a golf course parking lot. The court reinstated her claim, holding that the doctrine does not apply to someone who was not actually participating in an athletic or recreational activity when she was hurt, even if the accident happened at a recreational venue.

New York courts continue to apply the assumption of risk doctrine narrowly, limiting it to sports and recreational activities and excluding risks that are concealed or unreasonably enhanced.  As these decisions show, whether a claim survives often depends on whether the injury resulted from a risk inherent in the activity or from a condition that went beyond it. If you have been injured during a sport or recreational activity, you may still have a claim.

Giulia R. Marino, Esq.

Secret Link